1stWhistle is reader-supported. This article contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
When the Coaches Won’t Stop Talking About the Backup, Pay Attention
Every spring, a depth-chart name gets talked up by a coaching staff, and every spring, fans learn to apply the discount. So when Kyle Whittingham and his new staff started raving about true freshman Tommy Carr in March and April, the skepticism was fair — talking up one of the younger arms in a reshuffled quarterback room is the oldest trick in the coachspeak book. Then the spring game happened, and Carr made the skeptics look slow. It’s quietly the most interesting storyline in Ann Arbor heading into 2026 — and it has almost nothing to do with the depth chart.
The Bloodlines Are Almost Too On-the-Nose
Start with the name, because it’s a great one. Carr is the grandson of Lloyd Carr, the Hall of Fame coach who won Michigan’s 1997 national title, and of Michigan legend Tom Curtis on the other side — both College Football Hall of Famers. His father, Jason, was a Michigan quarterback in the ’90s; his brother, CJ, is the starting quarterback at Notre Dame. Tommy grew up in Saline, minutes from campus, earned All-State honors at Saline High, and reached the state semifinals in back-to-back years. He was committed to Miami (Ohio) before the bigger programs came calling — and once Michigan did, the kid with maize-and-blue in his bloodline flipped. It’s the kind of homecoming story that writes itself. The football is what makes it more than a story.
What Actually Happened in the Spring Game
Michigan held its spring game on April 18 in front of roughly 35,000 at the Big House, and Carr ran the show. He finished 21-of-30 (70%) for 143 yards and added 59 on the ground — but more than the numbers, it was how he played: poised in the pocket, calm against pressure, athletic enough to escape and create. The caveats are real and worth stating plainly: spring games are glorified scrimmages, and plenty of a freshman’s reps come against backups. But poise and processing speed don’t fake well, and a true freshman who enrolled in January isn’t supposed to look this comfortable in April.
The Whittingham Quotes Tell You What the Staff Sees
Whittingham didn’t soften it afterward, calling Carr the spring’s “most pleasant surprise” and praising his poise in the pocket, his knack for extending plays, and his ability to keep his eyes downfield. Earlier in the spring he’d already singled Carr out as the quarterback standing out behind Underwood. And it wasn’t just the arm: Whittingham has described Carr as a film-room junkie with the “it factor” — the field-general confidence you can’t coach. That’s not the language of a coach propping up a thin room. That’s a staff that thinks it found something.
Where This Goes From Here
Let’s be clear about the present: Bryce Underwood is the starter, and Whittingham reaffirmed it immediately after the spring game — even on a day Underwood was limited to a single quarter and went 3-of-9 for 22 yards. Carr’s realistic 2026 ceiling is winning the backup job, and even that isn’t handed to him; he’ll battle Colorado State transfer Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, who brings 28 career starts to the room. Carr still needs to add weight and adjust to the speed of the college game — he’s a three-star recruit, not a finished product. But the trajectory is what matters. A freshman this far ahead of schedule, with this pedigree, this work ethic, and this much staff belief, is the kind of insurance policy every program wants and few actually have. If Underwood takes the leap Michigan expects, Carr develops in the shadows for a year. If anything goes sideways, the Wolverines may have already met the answer.
The Bottom Line
Tommy Carr didn’t just survive his first Michigan spring — he turned manufactured hype into earned hype, in front of the home crowd, on the field his grandfather once coached. Backup quarterbacks don’t usually get features written about them in May. This one earned his.
Want the sharpest takes on Michigan and every team that matters, dropped in your inbox each morning? Subscribe free to the 1stWhistle Daily Sports Digest.
Go Blue, next gen: Shop Michigan Wolverines gear on Fanatics.